2012 Excellence in
Journalism Awards
June 28,
2013
Manoa Grand
Ballroom
Here are the winners in the 2012
Excellence in Journalism contest. Entries were judged by the Indiana Chapter of
SPJ.
DAILY NEWSPAPER
CATEGORY
Spot News
Reporting
First
Place
"Wait, see for
Maui"
Nanea Kalani, Melissa Tanji, Chris Hamilton,
Tressa Verber
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “Solid coverage
that touched all the bases.”
Finalists
“Oracle Corp. CEO
to buy Lanai”
Nanea Kalani, Melissa
Tanji
Maui
News
“Man pulls a
gun”
Lila Fujimoto
Maui
News
General
News/Enterprise Reporting
First Place
“Solid
Waste”
Nancy Cook Lauer,
Erin Miller
West Hawaii
Today
Judge’s
comments: "This package
clearly has the best material in the category, but the reporters and editor need
to do a better job of tying it together for the reader. It begins with strong
facts suggesting a watchdog story is in store. But there's no nut graph and no
attempt to tell the reader why so much money is being wasted. On the jump, the
story loses its focus and lets public officials off the hook. I would stay on
this story. Keep digging. "
FINALISTS
“No Kayak for
You”
Erin
Miller
West Hawaii
Today
Judge’s
comments: "This story has
a strong lede and is told authoritatively. I'd like to see more on the economic
impact of closing the bay to tours. I'd like to see more on the importance of
this to tourists and recreation. In other words, more impact."
“Wailuku Main
Street”
Ilima
Loomis
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “This story
exposes a clear problem about accountability for this nonprofit. I love some of
the digging the reporter did. I'd like to see the reporter go beyond the
government agency and the nonprofit. How accountable are other nonprofits that
take government money? What do experts in the field think? Is the new
administration putting the squeeze on other nonprofits or did it find issues
with just this one? How important is this nonprofit to the community? What do
real people think about its work in the community? Are there political
connections I'm missing? Is this a group of powerful people in the community not
accustomed to being questioned?”
Category
comments: "I thought the
stories in this category could have been stronger. Many are short dailies that
go little beyond the officials I would expect the reporters to contact.
The Scales of
Justice story seems like an ambitious project that lacked a clear focus. It
could have been helped with stronger editing and storytelling. The first few
sentences have compelling information, but perhaps the team could have found a
stronger way to top the story. Leading with a records request is a little too
dry for most readers. "
Feature
Writing/Short Form
First
Place
“Marines form
unusual friendship with lion”
Carolyn
Lucas-Zenk
West Hawaii
Today
Finalists
"Ride, Zaly
ride"
Chelsea
Jensen
West Hawaii
Today
“Pu‘u
O‘o”
Colin
Stewart
Hawaii
Tribune-Herald
Feature
Writing/Long Form
First
Place
“Vanilla
skies”
Carla
Tracy
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “Informative and
engaging”
Feature Page
Design
First
Place
“Faces of
survival”
Meg
Scarbrough
Hawaii
Tribune-Herald
Judge’s
comments: "This winning
design clearly stood out from the competition by emphasizing storytelling
through faces, images and copy blocks, without relying on gimmicks or cluttering
the page."
Category
comment: "Entries were
high in energy and effort, although some took design elements to the extreme and
not to the benefit of the reader. The winning entry had the right combination of
sophistication and reader-first approach."
NONDAILY
NEWSPAPER
General
News/Enterprise Reporting
First
Place
"Hi on Ice
(Cream)"
James
Cave
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: "Well
researched, well sourced, well told. Nice headline too.”
Finalists
"The Invisibles;
Come to Table"
Wanda A.
Adams
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: “Loved the
story. But not the lead: Too much, literally, and too much focus on list of big
names and where they are or are not. Once we get to the invisibles, the story
flows."
"David Murdock
trying to sell Lanai"
Duane
Shimogawa
Pacific Business
News
Judge’s
comments: “A good, newsy
read."
Feature
Writing
First
Place
"Her Natural
Home"
Mindy
Pennybacker
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: “This piece is
highly informative re: green construction
but manages to also be interesting by telling the story through one
family's experience."
Finalist
"Tackling the
All-Marine Rugby Team"
Christine
Cabalo
Hawaii
Marine
Judge’s
comments: “An interesting
look at how working on one's hobby (in this case rugby) can help one in one's
profession (soldiering), Liked how the writer did not go overboard on the small
size of the guy playing a physically demanding sport. That fact is significant,
of course, but the story is more than that (some feature writers wouldn't get
past it)."
Community
Reporting
First
Place
"Country's Time;
Turtle Bay EIS; Saving what Matters"
Joan
Conrow, Blake McElheny, Gil Riviere
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: “Very thorough
reporting on an issue that is clearly close to the hearts of readers who live in
the community. A classic tale of development vs. nature. Good
stuff!"
Finalists
"Running with the
devil dogs"
Christine Cabalo
Hawaii
Marine
Judge’s
comments: “Loved the
photography and the story was nice, too. Captured the essence of community
involvement, a key role of newspapers."
“Buried Truth;
Rail Broke Burial Rules; Buying Rail Estate; Honolulu's Big Bus Shibai; Defend
Dillingham: or Get Ready for El Hell"
Tiffany Hervey,
Tom Coffman, Kevin O'Leary,
Matthew Kain, Curt
Sanburn"
Honolulu
Weekly
INTERNET
Online News
Reporting
First Place
“Can a White
Federal Agent Who Killed a Hawaii Local Get a Fair Trial?”
Nick
Grube
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “Strong writing
and reporting and choice of subject matter. Clear explanation of past and
present events. Nice to have clear links to other resources.”
Finalists
“Concerns Of
Voter Intimidation Raised In Cachola Victory”
Nick Grube, Chad
Blair, Michael Levine
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “Well-written
with good data and charts. Quotes stand out as strong. Good links to other
resources for more info.”
“McCormack, Wee
add more Lavaman crowns to trophy cabinets”
Karin Stanton,
Baron Sekiya
Hawaii
24/7
Judge’s
comments: “Very
interesting subject. Great detail and exposition. Video element was also strong
- makes good use of digital medium.”
Category
comments: "Strong writing,
reporting, editing and storytelling are common to the winners. Would love to see
even more digital elements when possible, but all the winners drew me into the
narrative and prompted me to read additional stories related to the contest
entry (and that's more important than the medium)."
Online Feature
Reporting
First
Place
“Land Barren:
Japanese Billionaire Is Raising Eyebrows, Razing Houses”
Adrienne
LaFrance
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “Loved it.
Well-written and really interesting story with great mystery. (If I have a
suggestion it would have be to include even more visuals of the
houses/properties.)”
Finalists
“Honolulu candy
makers resurrect dying Japanese craft”
Diane Ako, Tracy
Arakaki
Staradvertiserblogs.com
Judge’s
comments: “Fascinating
video on original subject matter. Well executed.”
“Inouye's Last
Wish Is Abercrombie's Biggest Burden”
Nick Grube, Chad
Blair
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “A fascinating
range of subject matter in this category. The winners were all well-written and
presented.”
Best Multimedia
Presentation
First
Place
“Jana's Story:
Life as an Underage Sex Trafficking Victim in Honolulu”
Malia Zimmerman,
Jim Dooley, Duncan Armstrong
Hawaii
Reporter
Judge’s
comments: “Comprehensive
in writing and video. Very Well Done!!”
Finalists
“VIDEO: Kahuku
Residents Fight To Save Homes From Developer”
Joe Rubin, Sophie
Cocke
Honolulu Civil
Beat
“FOCUS: Meet
Kenny Endo, The Taiko Drummer”
Nathan Eagle,
Anita
Hofschneider
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “The video is a
compliment to the written story instead of re-telling the story. Very well
done.”
Category
comment: “The entries in
this category were all very good making the decision very difficult. The top
choices show that multimedia journalism is excellent in
Hawaii.”
Best Overall News
Site
First
Place
“CivilBeat.com”
Staff
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: "The site is
clean, easy to navigate, and most importantly, dedicated to news."
Finalists
“Pacific Business
News.com”
Staff
Pacific Business
News
Judge’s
comments: “I can tell
that news is the top priority.”
“HawaiiReporter.com”
Malia Zimmerman
Hawaii
Reporter
Best Hawaii News
Blogger (1-person site)
First
Place
“All Hawaii
News”
Nancy Cook
Lauer
All Hawaii
News
Judge’s
comments: “This site
represents an impressive amount of work for a single blogger. And it's
incredibly informative. Nice job.”
Category
comment: “Only one entry
here but it's a good one.”
Best Hawaii
Features Blogger (1-person site)
First
Place
“Sugar
+ Shake”
Dawn Sakamoto
Paiva
Judge’s
comments: "This blog wins
the category because of its amazing photography and ability to make my stomach
growl. It's also nicely written, with just the right casual touch for a blog but
packed with enough information to make it a must-read. Loved this blog."
Finalist
“The Cat Dish.
The Adventures of Catherine Toth
Catherine
Toth
Judge’s
comments: “I appreciated
the variety of topics covered here and the emotional post about the writer's
grandparents.”
Category
comments: “Two nice
entries that I enjoyed reading.”
MAGAZINE
Business
Reporting
First
Place
“The
Stogeyman”
Michael
Shapiro
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: "Michael Shapiro
skillfully combines a personality profile, a business story and a unique slice
of Hawai'ian life in this engaging read. He places us right there in the tobacco
field with Les Drent in the first paragraph and rewards us with several ‘gold
coins’ throughout the piece."
Finalists
“Let's Make a
Deal”
Shara
Enay
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "Shara Enay
provides us with a fun, interesting look at the people that buy and sell outside
the typical realm of retail stores."
“Kakaako's
Building Boom”
Beverly
Creamer
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “Beverly
Creamer's article is a well-researched and comprehensive look at an important
transformation taking place in Hawai'i's urban landscape.”
Industry or Trade
Reporting
First
Place
“Dragon 'Em
Around”
David
Thompson
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “A well-written
look at the growing number of Chinese visitors and how they are being welcomed
by Honolulu's tourism industry. The inside look at one group's whirlwind tour of
the city is packed with interesting details that sets this entry apart in a
category full of good stories.”
Finalists
“Federal Law
Gives Hawaii Longliners Free Rein to Ignore International
Quota”
Patricia Tummons,
Teresa Dawson
Environment
Hawai'i
“Global
Orchards”
Janice Crowl, Michael Shapiro, Julia Steele
Hana
Hou!
Profile
First
Place
“Eric Yeaman
Revives an Island Icon”
Beverly
Creamer
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "Sharp prose and
thorough reporting combine to make a well-rounded, solid profile of an island
mover and shaker."
Finalists
“The Lava
Dwellers”
David
Thompson
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “A fascinating
examination of an eclectic community of real outsiders written with great
style.”
“New
World”
Beverly
Creamer
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “An often
nail-biting examination of the trials and triumphs of a local business organized
in a intriguing manner.”
Feature
Writing/Short Form
First
Place
“Being Hawaiian
men and women of worth”
Kathy Muneno,
John Matsuzaki
Ka Wai
Ola
Judge’s
comments: “An intriguing
story powered by graceful writing and strong reporting.”
Finalists
“In search of a
song”
Lynn Cook
Ka Wai
Ola
Judge’s
comments: "A book review,
a slice of history and a look at local culture make this story a satisfying
read."
“Seeing
Stars”
Derek
Paiva
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “It made me see
the sights – and the stars.”
Feature
Writing/Long Form
First
Place
“A Good
Egg”
Jennifer Meleana
Hee
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “A fascinating
first-person account of a woman's journey of egg donation. Honest and nicely
written.”
Finalists
“Create a
Business in 54 Hours”
Jason
Ubay
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "A useful,
lightly written description of a cutting-edge trend."
“Hawaii's Richest
People”
Dennis
Hollier
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “People love
stories about rich people. This one is breezy and tells readers what went on
behind the scenes to determine who's the richest.”
Page Design
First
Place
“Best of Hawaii
2012”
Mae
Ariola
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "Comprehensive
and intriguing, every section of this Best of Hawaii mixes beautiful photography
with fun illustrations to make an editorial package that keeps the pages
turning. Subdued color palette for the backgrounds and graphic elements allow
the images to pop. A nice variety of photography from many angles. This ""Best
Of"" is the best of."
Finalists
“Going
Upcountry”
Mae
Ariola
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "Nothing says
country better than a chicken! The opening spread of ‘Growing Up Country’
captures the essence of the story beautifully. Gorgeous photography throughout
with great thought to the pacing of the feature."
“Honolulu in
1888: The City that Made the Magazine”
Cody Kawamoto
Honolulu
Magazaine
Judge’s
comments: "The ‘Honolulu
in 1888: The City That Made the Magazine’ is a great example of utilizing
existing resources and making them feel relevant and engaging. Graphic treatment
marries the subject matter perfectly and it feels just
right."
Magazine
Cover
First
Place
“November 2012:
Honolulu in 1888”
Cody
Kawamoto
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "With such a
rich history to draw upon, Honolulu's 125th anniversary cover feels both
nostalgic and modern at the same time. The typography is balanced and engaging.
The subject in the photo must have known he would be on the cover 125 years
later! Great quality for such an old image. Kudos for getting it
right!"
Finalists
“Bodies of
Art”
Shuzo Uemoto,
Keone Nunes, Sarah Pacheco, Nelson Gaspar
Ka Wai
Ola
Judge’s
comments: “Was immediately
drawn to the composition of the cover. The tattoos are in positions that flow
naturally for emphasis and become integral graphic elements to the overall
effect. Nice lighting on the photography.”
“Hawai'i Magazine
March/April issue”
Mae
Ariola
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “The lighting
and color gradations draw attention straight to the subject. Her board tilting
slightly upward gives a nice sense of motion and guides the reader to the cover
lines. Very pleasing to the eye.”
NEWSPAPERS
Business
Reporting
First
Place
“David Murdock
trying to sell Lanai”
Duane
Shimogawa
Pacific Business
News
Judge’s
comments: "This is a
complicated story, but the clear way it's written and the many interesting
details make it easy to follow. The reporter clearly worked hard to dig into
this sale and give it the coverage it deserved."
Finalists
“Checking
Out”
Erin Miller,
Chelsea Jensen
West Hawaii
Today
Judge’s
comments: "This could have
been a simple daily news story, but the context added made it more. The human element of hotel
employees woven into the narrative made it an engaging read. Well-written
deadline story."
“To market, but
where to?; Generation Next: Food Growers; Is There Hope for Ho'opili?"
Wanda A. Adams,
Tiffany Hervey, Kevin O'Leary
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: “The highlight
of this series is Kevin O'Leary's thoroughly researched overview of O'ahu's
land-use controversy.”
News Page
Design
First
Place
“Tribune-Herald,
A1”
Staff
Hawaii
Tribune-Herald
Judge’s
comments: "Nice page on
deadline, the equal play was the right choice given the news of the day. The top
2 photos were nice the down page photo about extended polling hours was hard
read. would have perhaps played up the run off photos bigger and forgone the
polling photo. also would have liked to see the return numbers out in display
type to emphasize the closeness of the race. That said election night pages are
hard to pull off and this one was nicely done. "
STUDENT
Student News
Reporting in Any Media
First
Place
“Tax
Pyramid”
Marcie Kagawa
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "Well
researched, reported and written. This entry gets the edge over the other
because it seems a little more complicated."
Finalist
“Hawaii Struggles
to Level the Playing Field”
Marcie Kagawa
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “Another great
entry. No problems here; the 1st place entry just seemed to tackle a slightly
more complicated issue.”
Category
comments: "Both of these
impressive entries were from the same reporter and you could tell. They are well
researched, reported and written. It was hard to choose."
Student Feature
Reporting in Any Media
First
Place
A Computer for
Every Student
Marcie
Kagawa
Hawaii Business
Judge’s
comments: “Well reported
and well written. Great combination. I felt like I learned a lot from this
story.”
Finalists
“Doing it
All”
Jennifer
Meyers
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “Great stories
about an interesting concept.”
“Heaven or
Hell”
Marcie
Kagawa
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “The strength of
this story is its good examples and nice research.”
Category
comments: "Overall, this
was a great group of student-written materia
RADIO
General
News/Enterprise Reporting
First
Place
“‘Mother Of
Outcasts’ To Be A Saint For Leprosy Work”
Heidi Chang
National Public
Radio
Feature
Reporting
First
Place
“Soundtracking
‘The Descendants’ With ‘Real’ Hawaiian Music
Judge’s
comments: “Terrific job of
weaving the music into the story, connecting it with what the subjects of the
piece were talking about.”
Heidi Chang, Tom
Cole
National
Public Radio
TELEVISION
Business
Reporting
First
Place
“New flights to
Fukuoka allow Hawaii residents to enjoy Kyushu”
Vanessa Stewart,
Taires Hiranaka
KHON2
General
News/Enterprise Reporting
“O'ahu's south
shores invaded by mysterious creature”
Brianne Randle,
Greg Lau
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “Interesting
story about millions of mysterious creatures washing up on shore and how experts
are trying to learn more about them. Great use of video and storytelling to draw
the viewers in to want to find out more.”
Finalists
“EXCLUSIVE: Ala
Moana murder suspect gives chilling interview”
Brianne
Randle
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “Great
enterprising story with an interview that shine the light on a murder suspect
for the public and police as the investigation continues.”
“Laptop stolen,
airline gate-check agent arrested”
Gina
Mangieri
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: "Great job
helping a viewer get assistance after her laptop was stolen. With a lack of
video because the crime happened in a different state, the report at least
provided pictures to show who did it and where it occurred."
Feature
Reporting
First
Place
“Honolulu candy
makers resurrect dying Japanese craft”
Diane Ako,
Tracy Arakaki
Diane
Ako
Judge’s
comments: “Great editing
nats and writing. What a feature story is about.”
Finalists
“Waipahu boy
diagnosed with cancer wants to meet The Rock”
Olena
Heu
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “Touching story
told well.”
“KHON SPECIAL:
Bee sting allergies and treatment”
Brianne
Randle
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “Great insight
into a personal story.”
Category
comments: “Very good
entries in this category. Candy
Makers distinguished itself among these three winners.”
Spot News
Reporting
First
Place
“Shark attack
survivor home from the hospital”
Brianne Randle,
Greg Lau
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “Nice story,
covered all angles."
Investigative
Reporting
First
Place
“Nanakuli
resident dumps trash in stream”
Kristine Uyeno,
Gina Mangieri, Brianne Randle
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: "Neighbor caught
polluting stream. Experts reveal chemical and other dangers to children, who
swim in polluted stream. As a result of the investigation, the state takes
action. Well told."
Videography
First
Place
“Honolulu candy
makers resurrect dying Japanese craft”
Diane Ako, Tracy
Arakaki
Diane Ako
Judge’s
comments: "A very nice
entry, terrific B-roll, good interviews, and it moves well. The children really
bring the piece home. Nice intro with the drumming and sushi. Criticisms would
be that it feels about 30 seconds too long, and blown audio at the beginning
with the Taiko drums. Nice entry.”
Category
comments: "Only one entry,
but the winner deserving of an award.
Good piece."
Series
Reporting/Documentary/Special News
First
Place
“St. Marianne:
Call of Devotion”
Gina Mangieri,
Taires Hiranaka
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: "Great
storytelling of the cannonization into sainthood. With limited video, the producers of
this report brought this story to life with good post production effects of old
pictures. Great to see a station
dedicate this much time and effort to an important part of
history."
Finalist
“Under the
Sea”
Justin Kanno,
Olena Heu
KHON2
Judge’s
comments: “A fascinating
look at the adventures in Hawaii underwater and above water. Great camerawork and use of
video.”
ALL
MEDIA
Column Writing or
Blog/News
First
Place
“Hawaii
Monitor”
Ian
Lind
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: "I love a
columnist that sees his or her job as an investigatory one. These columns were
enlightening and interesting - and I suspect forced some changes. Nice
job."
Finalists
“Board
Talk”
Teresa
Dawson
Environment
Hawai'i
Judge’s
comments: "Although this
entry is not what I typically think of as a column, I appreciate that it's a
place to hold public board accountable. I'm sure it is very well
read."
“Making the
scene”
Rick
Chatenever
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “This was the
most traditional of the entries and it was a good read.”
Category
comments: “Not your
typical collection of columns but they were all good for the
reader.”
Column Writing or
Blog/Features or Sports
First
Place
“Environment
Column: The Plant Hunter; Hail Snails!; Crop Sharing; Nest Building; Chase
Norton”
Sheila
Sarhangi
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "I didn't expect
rare fauna, snails and song birds to capture my interest but Sheila Sarhangi
found a multitude of different ways to do just that. From her writing (‘rosy
wolf snails — a cannibalistic snail from Florida that sucks native snails out of
their shells’ and ‘Millerbirds were wiped off Laysan Island in the early 1900s
after a series of destructive events, including a guano-mining operation and the
introduction of environmentally destructive rabbits’) to bizarre facts (poison
that reduces swelling of a broken arm, the various forms of protection for
snails)."
Finalists
"Afterthoughts”
Michael
Keany
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "Michael Keany's
collection of columns were a close second. Chinatown Lockdown was an excellent
look at a serious issue, Risky Business was an interesting piece on a new
phenomenon though I would have liked to have seen him take a stronger stand on
whether the ‘arcades’ were a positive or negative and Thinking Continental was a
nice contrast to the two news-ier columns."
"My Job: Bike
Messenger, Ocularist, Tattoo Artist, Recreating Elvis on Stage,
Entomologist"
Catherine Toth,
Stacy Yuen Hernandez, Michael Hanson
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "A neat idea. My
only complaint would be some of them left me wanting more information
(ocularist, Elvis impersonator)."
Government
Reporting
First
Place
"On the Trail of
the University of Hawaii’s Missing $200,000
Malia Zimmerman,
Jim Dooley
Hawaii
Reporter
Judge’s
comments: "Malia Zimmerman
and Jim Dooley of the Hawaii Reporter win this category for showing great
tenacity in flying across the country to knock on doors in search of those who
defrauded the University of Hawaii out of $200,000 by posing as agents for
Stevie Wonder. These stories give readers a look inside how the fake agents used
a UPS store mailbox as their world headquarters and many other details that
werenƒ??t available unless they went to the scene."
Finalists
Primary problems
to ponder
Nancy Cook
Lauer
West Hawaii
Today
Judge’s
comments: “This story
takes voters behind the scenes of a primary election mess in which many of
Hawaii County’s polls opened late and the state took over running the general
election. Nancy Cook Lauer makes outstanding use of public records to show that
top officials knew they had a mess on their hands before the primary but didn’t
work together to sort it out.”
Supreme Court
Weighs Jurisdiction in Appeal of Decision on Maui Water Teresa
Dawson
Environment
Hawai'i
Judge’s
comments: “This entry from
Environment Hawai‘i gives readers a comprehensive review of years of disputes
over West Maui water rights. A big-picture examination of the environmental
impact challenges surrounding the issue.”
Breaking News
Reporting
First
Place
"Wait, see for
Maui"
Nanea Kalani, Melissa Tanji, Chris
Hamilton
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: "This piece was
punctuated with a strong opening quote on an ‘overprediction’ followed by tons
of detail. Would have been great for a full days' work but only put together in
in a few hours. Great job by the staff."
Finalist
Will Bill Gates
or Larry Ellison buy Lanai?
Duane
Shimogawa
Pacific Business
News
Judge’s
comments: “I was very
intrigued by the concept of selling this island and all the reporter did to
track it done. An example of good work that can happen as a result of not giving
in.”
Health
Reporting
First
Place
“Saving
Healthcare”
Dennis
Hollier
Hawaii
Business
Finalists
“Professional
Addicts”
Matthew
Kain
Hawaii
Business
“A Good
Egg”
Jennifer Meleana
Hee
Honolulu
Magazine
Sports
Reporting
First
Place
“Surfing the
Stratosphere”
Paul Wood,
Michael Shapiro, Julia Steele
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: "Fascinating
read with vivid descriptions that take you into the wild, blue yonder of a sport
I never even knew existed. The writer does a terrific job mixing first-person
experiences with pure reporting – a tough mixture to pull off but it works in
this case. I think anyone who didn't know about this sport, including me, gets a
clear picture of why these men love to live life at the top of the world. Well
done!"
Finalists
“I Am A Roller
Derby Girl”
Tiffany
Hill
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "This is a
marvelous look inside the unique world of roller derby that I think any reader
can identify with. Not sure if I have more kudos for the writer's ability to
tell a first-person story with such imagery passion or the pure bravery of
playing this sport. Love the ""stage"" names, too."
“The Longest
Ia”
Ronald Williams,
Jr., Michael Shapiro, Julia
Steele
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: "The writer
skillfully tackles a tough story that makes for a compelling story. I'm sure it
was a hit with those on the islands and particularly with those who speak the
language. Also nice to see a sports story that goes deeper than wins and losses,
injuries and insult."
Category
comments: "Enjoyed reading all of the entries. The writing is fantastic, the
subject matter is interesting and the sports go well beyond the normal
ball-and-stick events that are the norm in so many other places. Thank you for
giving me an opportunity to get a glimpse into the very interesting world of
Hawaiian sports. It was a joy."
Arts/Entertainment
Writing
First
Place
“Songs of
Kalaupapa”
Derek Ferrar,
Michael Shapiro, Julia Steele
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: "Congrats to the
author for an educational, empathetic treatment of this subject matter. Dennis,
Stephen and Patrick move in and out of the story seamlessly, leaving room for an
appreciated history lesson. Effective use of song lyrics (in both languages).
Simply a report that will stick with readers for a long
time."
Finalists
“Hula
U.”
Liza Simon,
Michael Shapiro, Julia Steele
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: "A piece that
succeeds in conveying sense of place, as well as the charisma of Taupouri
Tangaro. High marks for this passage: ‘There is so much downward drive from the
piko (navel) in this room that I feel like I am a piston in a V8 engine of human
thighs.’"
My Scare
Lady
James
Cave
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: "A dynamic
first-person report.”
Category
comments: "Thanks for the
opportunity to read all this great work!
Editorial
Opinion
First
Place
“Critical Review
Should Have a Place in Reforestation Plans”
Patricia
Tummons
Environment
Hawai'i
Judge’s
comments: "This editorial
about reforestation plans for a 7,000-acre ranch poses many probing questions
about how state and federal officials have overseen the proposal and makes an
effective case in calling for more openness on how millions of dollars could be
spent."
Finalist
“Afterthoughts:
Chinatown Lockdown”
Michael
Keany
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “A well-written
and conversational piece that vividly explains the impact of crime on Honolulu's
Chinatown neighborhood.”
Editorial
Cartoon/Illustration
First
Place
“911 for the Life
Aquatic”
Michael
Byers
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “I loved looking
at this artwork. The color and the size comparison between the whale and the man
in the boat made me want to read the story. Excellent.”
Finalists
“Pritchett's Pen:
Victoria's Secret Service”
John
Pritchett
Hawaii
Reporter
Judge’s
comments: “Good used of
image, color and clever idea. The cartoon effectively mocks the Secret Service
for their members' failure in judgment."
“20 Things We
Love About Hawaii Right Now: We Never Arrive At A Party Empty-Handed Even If The
Host Insists/We Never Leave A Party Empty-Handed Because The Host
Insists”
Tony
Ablan
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “Effective
illustration that tells the story graphically.”
Category
comments: "Judging
editorial cartoons and illustrations are like comparing apples and oranges in
that their goal is entirely different things. Graphically, the entries in this
category were very strong."
Informational
Graphic
First
Place
“New Cool for
Downtown”
Jen Tadaki
Catanzariti
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "This news
graphic answers many of the important questions related to the project – the
size, the cost, the timeline and whom it will affect."
Category
comments: "Editors would
do well to remember that graphics editing isn't limited to the text in the
graphic – the visuals need an editing eye, too. Your bottled cry for help has
reached the mainland."
News
Photography/Videography
First
Place
“Hawaii a
privileged viewpoint for a rare display”
Matthew
Thayer
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “A compelling
lede photo made this photo series take first place. It was nice to see the
photographer made sure readers saw what the subjects in the photos were looking
at. A solid package.”
Finalists
“Hot new
ride”
Matthew
Thayer
Maui News
Judge’s
comments: “We could tell
the photographer is always prepared for spot news and was rewarded with this
compelling image. Good job.”
“Pahala wildfire
rages”
Hollyn
Johnson
Hawaii
Tribune-Herald
Judge’s
comments: “We believe the
two images displayed helped readers understand the impact of the fire on their
community. Some photographers may have been too quick to tighten their frame on
the firefighters but this photographer had the right presence of mind to show
the size of the blaze which made this entry a finalist.”
Feature
Photography/Videography
First
Place
“The Ti of
Life”
Leigh Morrison, Dana Edmunds, Samuel Leigh, Kunio Hayashi
Hana
Hou!
Judge’s
comments: “The detail and
colors of the plants are gorgeous and harmonious. The typography really enhances
it as well.”
Finalists
“The Lava
Dwellers"
Christine Hitt,
David Thompson, Vanessa Kaneshiro, Christian Vetter
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "Really
interesting story. The video really give the sense of being there, and what it
would be like. Fascinating to see the lava in its molten form."
Season of
Obon
Consuela Yokomura
HAWAI'I
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: "The composition
of each image is lovely, and the colors work well as a spread. Nice pairing. The
design enhances it all well. Engaging."
Category
comments: "I can
appreciate the skills needed to capture action photos, like in the newspaper
shots, and the firefighting story. There were more entries worthy of
mention."
Sports
Photography/Videography
First
Place
“Action-packed
day at Makawao Rodeo”
Matthew
Thayer
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: An
attention-grabbing lede photo set this entry apart from the rest. We imagined ourselves falling off the
back of the sheep after seeing the photo. Nice work by the photographer to be in
the right place at the right time.
Finalists
“Illinois no ka
oi”
Matthew Thayer
Maui
News
Judge’s
comments: “Nice to see
photographer waited for a unique and humorous moment to occur. His patience was
rewarded with a nice out-of-the-ordinary image.”
“I Am a Roller
Derby Girl”
Vanessa
Kaneshiro, Christine Hitt, Tiffany Hill
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “We found this
video entry to be a thorough explanation of a unique and uncommon sport. Great
quotes and transitions plus a robust length made this entry a
finalist.”
Photo/Video
Essay
First
Place
“Kalaupapa
Memories”
Wayne
Levin
Honolulu
Magazine
Judge’s
comments: “Amazing
portraits that grab you and lure you into the story. Artful and full of detail.
I love this feature. Very cohesive and holds together well to the end. Great
package.”
Finalists
“Brothers in
Fire”
Elyse Butler,
Matt Mallams, Leigh Morrison, Samuel Lee, Kunio Hayashi Hana Hou!
Judge’s
comments: “Beautiful
portraits. Consistent quality of images. Difficult to
shoot.”
“First
Responders”
David
Croxford
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "The
photographer clearly had to make a great effort to get these images, and was
possibly even in harm's way. Powerful."
Category
comments: “Great entries.
I love seeing a totally different culture/lifestyle than my own from the
perspective of the people who live there.”
Headlines
First
Place
"It May Look Like
Magic, but It's Hard Work, Smart People, Dumb Mistakes, Nothing is Better Than
Free”
Catherine Toth,
Jolyn Okimoto Rosa, Matthew Kain
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: "A good
collection of smart, imaginative headlines sets this entry apart. We like the
subtle play on words."
Finalists
"The Sho Must Go
On, Survival of the Fittest, Amber Waves, K-Hip, Endless
Winter"
Michael Shapiro, Julia
Steele
Hana
Hou!
“Descent Into
Haole: ‘The Descendants’ Land Barren: Japanese Billionaire is Raising Eyebrows,
Razing Houses”
Staff
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Best Reporting
Using Social Media
First
Place
Our Hawaiian
Spring: Facebook Voting Game Aims To Boost Voter Turnout Patti Epler, Heidi
Pliszka, Alice Terry Honolulu Civil Beat
Special
Section
First
Place
“Changing
Communities”
Beverly Creamer,
Dennis Hollier
Hawaii
Business
Judge’s
comments: “These stories
do an excellent job taking readers inside two very different communities as they
deal with changes brought on by new development. The good use of many viewpoints
shows deep reporting.”
Finalists
“Celebrate
Hula”
Tribune-Herald
staff
Hawaii
Tribune-Herald
“A Debt
Paid”
Naomi Sodetani,
Ricky Li, John Matsuzaki, Francine Murray, Lisa Asato
Ka Wai Ola
A118
Investigative Reporting
First
Place
"Boss GMO;
Monsanto Ed; Monsanto Protest; GMO Transparency; GMO
‘Candy’”
Tiffany Hervey,
Joan Conrow, Debbie Millikan
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: "Outstanding
investigation. An incredible amount of work done to chronicle the breadth of the
GMO seed industry in Hawaii, its far reach, the influence and money behind the
industry, the lack of regulation, and the dearth of testing regarding the safety
of genetically-modified foods.
Finalists
“Cops,
Prostitutes and Pimps – Series on Sex Trafficking in Honolulu"
Sara Lin
Honolulu Civil
Beat
Judge’s
comments: “Top-notch
investigation. Terrific data story: The numbers are incredibly revealing. Well
written. And backed by an editorial calling for change.”
"On the Trail of
the University of Hawaii’s Missing $200,000"
Malia Zimmerman,
Jim Dooley
Hawaii
Reporter
Judge’s
comments: Good old
shoe-leather reporting. The story keeps getting better and better. And the
university looks more and more stupid.
Best Independent
Journalist (not supported by an organization)
No
entries
Public Service
Reporting
First Place
Innovative HOPE
Probation Program Sharply Criticized
Jim Dooley
Hawaii
Reporter
Judge’s comments:
"Collection of
articles shows problems in a successful program, one that costs lives. No taking
sides, just highlighting concerns. Great work."
Finalists
High Surf Higher
Stakes
Donna
Ching
Honolulu
Weekly
Judge’s
comments: "Clear language
showing the need for supporting a public employee like lifeguards, and the
increasing role they play in public safety. Very engaging, couldn't stop
reading."
Hawaii's
Vanishing Voter – Special Report on Voter Participation
Ian Lind, Michael
Levine, Patt Epler
Honolulu Civil
Beat
THANK YOU TO THE
HAWAII JUDGES OF THE INDIANA SPJ CHAPTER’S CONTEST
Brad
Ballesteros
Jim Borg
Martha
Cheng
Christina
Chun
Linda
Cicotello
Linda
Dalrymple
Teresa
Dawson
Linda Dela Cruz
Bill Dorman
Susan
Essoyan
Dennis
Hollier
Sean Ibara
Stephanie
Kendrick
Nancy Cook
Lauer
Anne Lee
George Lee
Kristin
Lipman
Audrey
McAvoy
Stirling
Morita
Curtis
Murayama
Steve
Murray
Stirling
Morita
Dennis Oda
Lennie
Omalza
Mary Poole
Rob Perez
Steve
Petranik
Brianne Randle
Charlene
Robinson
Sam Spangler
Christine
Strobel
Dave Swann
Jen Tadaki
David
Thompson
Mary
Vorsino
Christi
Young
Lucy Young
Oda
Stacy
Yuen